OWR-782-001 · Complete proof

Extremal Modular Forms Modulo p and a Conjecture of Bannai, Koike, Shinohara and Tagami

Manuscript 1 October 2026 · Online 1 October 2026

math.NTUnrefereed preprint

Abstract

For even \(k\ge4\) let \(f_k\)\({}=1\)\({}+O(q^{\dim M_k})\) be the extremal modular form of weight \(k\) for \(\mathrm{SL}_2(\mathbb{Z})\). Bannai, Koike, Shinohara and Tagami conjectured that if \(k=12\mu\) and \(f_k\bmod p\) is a nonconstant power series in \(q^p\) (their Case (2)), then \(f_k(\tau)\)\({}\equiv g(p^r\tau)\pmod p\) for an extremal modular form \(g\) of smaller weight and some \(r\ge1\). We observe that this is a corollary of the classical theory of modular forms modulo \(p\): the key input is the equality \(w(h^p)=p\,w(h)\) for the filtration of a \(p\)-th power, which follows from Swinnerton-Dyer's structure theorem and underlies the theorem of Serre and Katz on the kernel of \(\theta\). For every even \(k\ge4\) and every prime \(p\) in Case (2) we get \(f_k(\tau)\)\({}\equiv f_{k'}(p\tau)\pmod p\) with \(k'=w(f_k\bmod p)/p\), where \(4\le k'\le k/p\) and \(k'\equiv k\pmod{p-1}\). So the conjecture holds with \(r=1\), and by iteration also with the largest possible \(r\). For \(k=12\mu\) every prime in Case (2) satisfies \(11\le p\le3\mu\) and \(p\ne13\), and Case (2) is decided by a finite test. Exact computations for all weights \(12\mu\le7200\) and all even \(k\le2400\), covering \(9433\) pairs \((k,p)\) in Case (2), agree with these statements. This is an unrefereed note.

Record

Affiliation
Mercury Software GmbH
Result
Complete proof
Categories
math.NT
Manuscript
1 October 2026
Online release
1 October 2026
Version
1.0
License
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International

Files and verification

The PDF is the canonical reading copy. The source archive contains the LaTeX manuscript, bibliography, reproducibility material, and audit documents without build artefacts.

Citation

Alper Ferudun, “Extremal Modular Forms Modulo p and a Conjecture of Bannai, Koike, Shinohara and Tagami,” EulerSolve Research Papers, OWR-782-001, 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23071924.

BibTeX
@misc{Ferudun2026Owr782001,
  author = {Ferudun, Alper},
  title = {Extremal Modular Forms Modulo p and a Conjecture of Bannai, Koike, Shinohara and Tagami},
  year = {2026},
  howpublished = {EulerSolve Research Papers},
  url = {https://eulersolve.org/papers/owr-782-001/},
  doi = {10.5281/zenodo.23071924},
  note = {OWR-782-001; unrefereed preprint}
}

More research papers

Show all 474 other papers

All 475 research papers →