A Negative Answer to the Strong Geography Question of Alfieri and Binns
Manuscript 30 September 2026 · Online 30 September 2026
Abstract
Alfieri and Binns say that an \(\mathbb{F}[U]\)-module \(M\) satisfies the strong geography restriction if it has a direct summand \(\mathbb{F}[U]\)\(/U^\ell\)\({}\oplus\mathbb{F}[U]\)\(/U^{\ell-1}\)\({}\oplus\)\(\dots\)\({}\oplus\mathbb{F}[U]\)\(/U\), where \(\ell\) is the least integer with \(U^\ell M_{\mathrm{red}}\)\({}=0\). They showed that \(\mathit{HF}^-(Y)\) satisfies it when \(Y\) is surgery on a knot in \(S^3\) or large surgery on a link, and asked whether it holds for every rational homology sphere \(Y\). We show that the answer is no. For the Brieskorn sphere \(Y=\Sigma(30,47,83)\), with either orientation, the reduced Heegaard Floer homology is \(\mathcal{T}_{16}\)\({}\oplus\mathcal{T}_{14}^{10}\)\({}\oplus\mathcal{T}_{13}^{16}\)\({}\oplus\)\(\dots\)\({}\oplus\mathcal{T}_{1}^{92}\), where \(\mathcal{T}_{k}\)\({}=\mathbb{F}[U]\)\(/U^k\). So \(\ell=16\), but \(\mathbb{F}[U]/U^{15}\) is not a direct summand of \(\mathit{HF}^-(Y)\). The proof combines the Ozsváth–Szabó description of \(\mathit{HF}^+\) for plumbed manifolds, Némethi's reduction to the graded root of an explicit function \(\tau\), and an exact computer calculation. We give a certificate, the \(1707\) turning points of \(\tau\), from which the summand lengths can be rechecked by a short program. The manifold \(Y\) is an irreducible integral homology sphere, is not an \(L\)-space, and satisfies Lin's weaker restriction. It also shows that the word “large” cannot be removed from the link-surgery theorem of Alfieri and Binns. Computer searches with two independent programs show that among Seifert fibred integral homology spheres \(\Sigma(a_1,\)\(\dots,a_n)\), the counterexamples with the smallest product \(a_1\cdots a_n\) are \(\Sigma(30,47,83)\) and three spheres with four singular fibres, all of product \(117030\). This is an unrefereed note.
Record
- Affiliation
- Mercury Software GmbH
- Contact
- [email protected] · GitHub
- Result
- Complete negative answer (computer-assisted)
- Categories
- math.GT
- Manuscript
- 30 September 2026
- Online release
- 30 September 2026
- Version
- 1.0
- License
- Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
Files and verification
The PDF is the canonical reading copy. The source archive contains the LaTeX manuscript, bibliography, reproducibility material, and audit documents without build artefacts.
Citation
Alper Ferudun, “A Negative Answer to the Strong Geography Question of Alfieri and Binns,” EulerSolve Research Papers, OWR-14298580-008, 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23063072.
BibTeX
@misc{Ferudun2026Owr14298580008,
author = {Ferudun, Alper},
title = {A Negative Answer to the Strong Geography Question of Alfieri and Binns},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {EulerSolve Research Papers},
url = {https://eulersolve.org/papers/owr-14298580-008/},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.23063072},
note = {OWR-14298580-008; unrefereed preprint}
}