The Harrell–Stubbe Gap Inequality for Dirichlet Eigenvalues Is Never Saturated
Manuscript 30 September 2026 · Online 30 September 2026
Abstract
Let \(E_1\le E_2\le\cdots\) be the eigenvalues of the Dirichlet Laplacian on a bounded open set \(\Omega\)\({}\subset\mathbb{R}^n\), and let \(M_p(J)\)\({}=\big(\frac{n+2p}{n}\frac1J\sum_{j\le J}E_j^p\big)^{1/p}\). Harrell and Stubbe proved that \(M_1(J)^2\)\({}-M_2(J)^2\)\({}\ge\frac14(E_{J+1}\)\({}-E_J)^2\), and in a problem list of the 2009 Oberwolfach workshop on low eigenvalues of Laplace and Schrödinger operators they asked whether some \(\Omega\) and \(J\) saturate this inequality. We show that the answer is no: the inequality is strict for every bounded open set and every \(J\). Written in terms of the mean and the variance of \(E_1,\dots,E_J\), the inequality is a gap estimate of Cheng and Yang, so that estimate is strict as well. The proof analyses the case of equality in the Harrell–Stubbe trace identity behind H. C. Yang's inequality. Equality would put each function \(x_ku_1\), where \(u_1\ge0\) is a first eigenfunction, into a finite sum of eigenspaces. Then every partial derivative of \(u_1\) would lie in \(H^1_0(\Omega)\), so \(\int_\Omega\Delta u_1\)\({}=0\), which is impossible because \(\Delta u_1=-E_1u_1\). The same argument shows that Yang's first inequality is strict whenever \(E_{J+1}\gt E_1\), and hence for every \(J\) when \(\Omega\) is connected; in 2002 Ashbaugh left the strictness of this inequality undecided. By contrast, for the harmonic oscillator and on spheres the analogous bounds are equalities at every spectral gap, that is, for every \(J\) with \(E_J\lt E_{J+1}\). This is an unrefereed note.
Record
- Affiliation
- Mercury Software GmbH
- Contact
- [email protected] · GitHub
- Result
- Complete negative answer
- Categories
- math.SP · math.AP
- Manuscript
- 30 September 2026
- Online release
- 30 September 2026
- Version
- 1.0
- License
- Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
Files and verification
The PDF is the canonical reading copy. The source archive contains the LaTeX manuscript, bibliography, reproducibility material, and audit documents without build artefacts.
Citation
Alper Ferudun, “The Harrell–Stubbe Gap Inequality for Dirichlet Eigenvalues Is Never Saturated,” EulerSolve Research Papers, OWR-3389-016, 2026. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23064381.
BibTeX
@misc{Ferudun2026Owr3389016,
author = {Ferudun, Alper},
title = {The Harrell–Stubbe Gap Inequality for Dirichlet Eigenvalues Is Never Saturated},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {EulerSolve Research Papers},
url = {https://eulersolve.org/papers/owr-3389-016/},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.23064381},
note = {OWR-3389-016; unrefereed preprint}
}